Keeping the air fresh and flowing is the best way to get a fresh environment. Whether you are at home or the office, maintaining motion of the air will change the atmosphere and even bring rejuvenation. With the advancement of technology, there is a wide array of air circulators Vs fan for you to choose from. Ultimately the choice will boil down to your specific needs and taste.

Air Circurator Vs Fan – The Main Differennces

Discussion Topic #1: Types

Traditional Fans

Five types of fans are very popular among the household customers

1. Ceiling fan

As the name suggests, the ceiling fan is a traditional fan that is fitted on the ceiling. It usually comes equipped with a rod for the purpose. The ceiling fan creates a comfortable environment in the room. The fan works best in the hot summer days by providing efficient air circulation.

2. Tower fan

The beauty of the tower fan is that it gives superior airflow by taking up minimum space. Its compact build makes it perfect for small spaces. Size is not an issue though because the tower fan still provides clean fresh air through ionization and is relatively quiet.

3. Pedestal fan

The fan is ideal for large spaces and has different modes of circulation depending on your preference. Most pedestal fans come with a detachable stand and adjustable tilt making them easier to operate and adjust to facing the desired direction.

4. Table fan

The table fan is ideal for bedrooms and offices due to its portable design. The fan ensures you have a cool airflow owing to superior airflow capabilities. The good oscillation gives it a good range. This electric fan is relatively quiet and will not be a distraction either when sleeping or working.

5. Wall mount fan

The best thing about this fan is that it gives full room air circulation. The wall mount fan is easy to assemble and mount on the wall.

Air circulators

The three main types of air circulators are:

1. Tower air circulator

The tower air circulator comes equipped with a motor that produces a higher volume of air. Like its cousin, the traditional tower fan, this cooling system is compact size. The circulator offers full circulation of air in a room.

2. Pedestal air circulator

This air circulator is ideal for large spaces because it offers a good range of air flow. Another advantage of the pedestal air circulator is the multi-directional function that allows it to work in many directions according to preference. It is relatively quiet and has speed settings.

3. Table air circulator

This circulator is ideal for personal use due to its small size. Most come with a swivel that allows it to circulate air evenly in a room. It comes equipped with a powerful oscillator that gives off a cool breeze with minimal noise.

Discussion Topic #2: Working Mechanism

There is a difference in the working mechanism of air circulators Vs fan which dictates how they operate and their capabilities.

How Traditional Fan Works

The electric fan has an electric motor that helps it to function. The electric motor is connected to metallic blades through a hub at the center of the fan. Through electromagnetic induction, the motor causes the blades to turn when the electric current passes through it. When the electric motor drives the blades, they in turn slice through the air causing air to circulate downward from the ceiling.

The blades are shaped at an angle for maximum effect so when they cut through the air, air moves to replace the air that has been pushed down. This action causes air to be circulated across the room.

How an Air Circulator Works?

Like their traditional counterparts, air circulators have curved blades attached to it. However, air circulators work differently by use of centrifugal forces that pull air to the edges of the fast-spinning blades. The hot air that has been drawn into the jet stream is directed elsewhere in form of an invisible jet stream leaving cool fresh air to take up space.

Discussion Topic #3: Uses

Both the traditional fan and the air circulator have primarily the same uses. But with the difference in their functionality, the traditional fan is ideal for some places and the air circulator for others. Let us find out more about where to use air circulator Vs fan.

Where to use the traditional fan

a) Indoor use

1. The living room

The pedestal fan is best suited for the living room because of its range. The living room needs a fan with a good range that will allow maximum circulation of air in the whole room. The ceiling fan is also ideal for the living room since it circulates air evenly across the whole space.

  1. The bedroom

The table fan comes in handy for spaces such as the bedroom. The fan is relatively quiet meaning it will not be a distraction to you. The table fan also comes in different designs that you can choose from to reflect your personal style in your room. Despite its small size, the fan still gives superior air flow to give you cool air.

b) Outdoor use

The misting fan is great for outdoor use. It works with the same principal as a humidifier blasting a fine of mist water into the air. The water evaporates bringing a cooling effect. For those hot summer days, a misting fan will help cool the temperature for your children and pets to enjoy the bright sunny day. Other fans that would work great for the outdoors are the portable fans with USB which are great for use in the car and when camping.

Where to use the air circulator fan

The beauty with air circulators is that they can work well in any season of the year. Whether it is snowing or blistering, you can tune your air circulator to handle your immediate air conditioning needs. Air circulators work well in enclosed places and are therefore ideal for workplaces and even industries.

They are also those that are ideal for home use.

Discussion Topic #4: Oscillation

Air circulators oscillate at 360˚ drawing in hot air and streaming elsewhere as an invisible jet stream. This causes the air in the room to circulate and every part of the room to receive fresh air. This oscillation causes air circulators to be effective at removing stale air in a room. The traditional ceiling fan also oscillates at 360˚ making it perfect for the living room.

Other types of fans like the pedestal and tower fan oscillate at 90° which means they only blow the air that is directly in contact at that angle. You will have to sit directly opposite these fans to enjoy the flow of air.

Discussion Topic #5: Benefits of Air Circulator over traditional fans

Although both air circulator Vs fan has different uses and working mechanisms, the air circulator should be your preferred choice for the following reasons:

  1. All air circulators oscillate at 360˚ which means cool fresh air for you across the room. On the other hand, not all traditional fans work at this angle limiting their range.
  2. Air circulators keep the air in the room in constant motion while fans only blow air that is directly in contact with them.
  3. The air circulator cools the room efficiently because it keeps air in motion, by pointing it up, the circulator will cool the room faster by keeping the hot air ( that rises to the ceiling) and the cool air (that sinks to the floor) moving.
  4. Air circulators ultimately save energy compared to traditional fans

Discussion Topic #6: Power Consumption and Cost

The energy consumption and cost of running air circulator Vs fan depends on factors such as the speed setting and the wattage.

Air Circulator

SettingWatts
Low29
Medium36
High45
Turbo56

 

Fan

Fans have different power consumption depending on the type. The tower fan consumes the most power of 54W-100W from low to the highest setting. The desk fan consumes the least at 10W-30W.

Below is a table showing the consumption of a pedestal fan when used for four hours a day.

SettingWatts
Low35
Medium55
High70

 

Discussion Topic #8: Cleaning

Although the difference in noise production between air circulators Vs fans is not major, air circulators are noisier than their traditional counterparts.

Air circulators produce between 60-65 dB (decibels) while the traditional fans produce an average of 50-60 dB depending on the type of the fan.

Discussion Topic #9: Speed

The ceiling fan boasts of the highest average CFM. The table below illustrates the type of fan and the speed.

 

Type of FanAverage CFM
Air Circulator700-800
Tower fan600-800
Ceiling fan4000-5000
Pedestal fan2000-3000

Wrap Up

Air conditioning is an essential part of daily life, and that is why it is imperative to pick the right type of fan depending on your needs.

From the above information, it is clear that air circulators work with the most efficiency to circulate air in a room. On the other hand ceiling and pedestal fans have the most speed.

There is a wide variety of air circulators Vs fan to pick from. Depending on your preference and the function of the equipment you have a choice. There are air circulators that produce minimal noise and still offer a good oscillation range.

Reference:

https://www.dimplex.com.au/blog/air-circulators-vs-traditional-fans

https://www.canstarblue.com.au/energy/electricity/portable-fans-running-costs/